| Position | First Team | Second Team | Third Team | Fourth Team |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 |  |  |  |  |
QB | Drew Lock | Jack Lowary | Micah Wilson | Hayden Rymer |
RB | Damarea Crockett | or Ish Witter | Nate Strong | Dawson Downing |
TE | Jason Reese | Albert Okwuegbunam | Brendan Scales | |
WR | J'Mon Moore | Nate Brown | Dominic Collins | Cameren Rivers |
WR | Johnathon Johnson | Ray Wingo | Richaud Floyd | Steven Spadarotto |
WR | Dimetrios Mason | Emanuel Hall | Justin Smith | Daniel Ellinger |
LT | Tyler Howell | Yasir Durant | ||
LG | Kevin Pendleton | A.J. Harris | Kyle Mitchell | |
C | Alec Abeln | or Sam Bailey | Jonah Dubinski | Trystan Castillo |
RG | Adam Ploudre | Tre'Vour Simms | ||
RT | Paul Adams | Pompey Coleman | Tommy Grossman |
| Position | First Team | Second Team | Third Team | Fourth Team |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 |  |  |  |  |
DE | Spencer Williams | Nate Howard | Eddie Cruz | Jordan Harold |
DT | Terry Beckner Jr. | Jordan Harold | Adam Roland | Rashad Brandon |
DT | A.J..Logan | Markell Utsey | Tyrell Jacobs | |
DE | Marcell Frazier | Tre Williams | Franklin Agbasimere | |
LB | Brandon Lee | Grant Jones | Tavon Ross | T.J. Warren |
LB | Eric Beisel | Cale Garrett | Jake Trump | Joe Hoy |
LB | Terez Hall | Joey Burkett | Roderick Winters | |
CB | DeMarkus Acy | Finis Stribling IV | Jerod Alton | |
CB | Christian Holmes | Logan Cheadle | Sean Boyd | |
SS | Ronnell Perkins | Anthony Sherrils | Anthony Hines | Ryan Dalley |
FS | Cam Hilton | Thomas WIlson | Kaleb Prewett | Dominic Nelson |
| Position | First Team | Second Team | Third Team |
|---|---|---|---|
 |  |  |  |
PK | Tucker McCann | or Nick Bartolotta | or Andrew Carr |
LS | Harley Whitehouse | James Workman | |
P | Corey Fatony |
